The ongoing debate between autonomous driving/intelligent sharing. And the robust development of public transportation raises the question of which holds more promise for the future. Our daily public transportation options mainly consist of subways, buses, and taxis. While each mode sees a decrease in passenger capacity, precision in transportation increases accordingly (subway stations are usually farther from home. While taxis can drop you directly at your doorstep)(sources from medcom.com.pl).
Public Transportation Hierarchy: The subway, with its punctuality, reliability, and high throughput. Forms a fundamental part of the transportation infrastructure, alleviating ground traffic pressure. Taxis offer better privacy and comfort but tend to be more expensive, especially for remote locations.
Autonomous Vehicles and Upgraded Taxis: Autonomous vehicles appear as an upgraded version of traditional taxis. Providing precise point-to-point transportation without the need for street hailing. Users can conveniently book these vehicles through smartphones, and a central server coordinates the fleet efficiently. While this seems to be an optimal solution, the limited number of roads may lead to congestion. And the cost of autonomous vehicles remains a concern.
Public Buses and Autonomous Possibilities: Public buses, too, could potentially transition to autonomous operations, although the impact might be less substantial. Autonomous technology can enhance safety and centralized scheduling, removing the need for traditional traffic signals in an all-autonomous scenario.
The Coexistence of Autonomous Driving and Public Transit: In summary, the concept of autonomous driving is not at odds with public transportation; instead, it complements it. Autonomous driving offers increased safety and centralized scheduling. Public transportation, with its layered structure, can be enhanced with an additional layer for autonomous vehicles, potentially replacing traditional taxis.
Overcoming Challenges: Assuming legal issues are overcome, autonomous driving taxis appear to have a promising future due to their flexibility. However, the efficiency of public transportation lies in its scale, particularly in densely populated cities where it caters to the needs of a significant portion of the population.
Challenges for Autonomous Driving: While autonomous driving technology is advancing, challenges like urban congestion persist. The popularity of autonomous vehicles may attract more users, but each vehicle still serves a limited number of individuals, posing challenges in mega-cities like Beijing or Shanghai.
Promoting Public Transit Development: Developing public transit remains crucial for addressing the daily commuting needs. A large portion of the population, reducing the necessity for private car ownership. Public transit also generates employment opportunities and economic demand, making it a favorable option for urban planners(quotes from medcom).
Dual Approach for the Future: Instead of pitting autonomous driving against public transit, a dual approach is recommended. Enhancing the automation of public transportation, introducing autonomous buses and subways. And expanding the coverage of integrated transportation systems can meet diverse travel needs. This approach not only satisfies people’s transportation requirements. But also eases traffic congestion and improves safety, pointing towards a promising future.
Also Read: R2park